User
Pass
2FA
 
 

[FIXED] [Priest][Discipline] Atonement

 
This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics.   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    Freakz Forum Index -> WoW Freakz - Legion -> Bug Report -> Fixed bugs
Show only staff posts
Author Message1001
Lhiithium

[Mentally Stable]



Status: Offline
(online 5 hours ago)
Joined: 31 Aug 2017
Posts: 15, Topics: 6
Location: Romania

Reputation: 60.5
Votes: 1

Post Posted: 11-03-2019, 13:28:26 | Translate post to: ... (Click for more languages)

WoW Freakz spell link: Atonement
Bug description: Healing transferred through Atonement is too high.
Proof: Let's start by looking at this priest's numbers (minute 9.05). Look at the date, it's not a PTR vid.
So, his base Atonement healing of 40% is increased by 40.1% of his mastery which means 56% healing transferred through Atonement.
Now, let's take a look at the damage and healing of Purge the Wicked here (minute 10.57)

53 323 damage and 21 813 healing
Let's do the math, 56.1/100 * 53 323 = 29 914 > 21 813 (his)

Why is the healing he's doing lower than the math one?
An explanation is given here, a post from the around the same time with the video.
Long story short, if you read from the 6th post below, some damage modifiers on Light's Wrath don't transfer through Atonement.

"Yep. In particular the bonuses that increase Damage AND Healing do not double dip when it comes to atonement transfer."

This is a video of my priest healing through Atonement.
Let's do the math again, 59% healing through Atonement which should be lower because of the above argument and proof.

59/100 * 290 969 = 171 745 < 184 731 (mine)
59/100 * 541 938 = 319 743 < 369 338 (mine)

Not only the heal is not equal with 59%, but bigger, and it should be smaller.
The calculations I've done are rough and not take into consideration Versatility or other modifiers that I don't know about, but regardless, the difference is not small.



Last edited by Lhiithium on 11-03-2019, 19:13:10; edited 1 time in total
5 0
  
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
decenu

[Best Paladin Holy]



Status: Offline
(online 1 day ago)
Joined: 14 Oct 2011
Posts: 491, Topics: 19
Location: Bucuresti

Reputation: 211.5
Votes: 18

 
Post Posted: 11-03-2019, 14:10:17 | Translate post to: ... (Click for more languages)

Confirmed


0 0
  
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Elvenking

[Helper]



Status: Offline
(online 12 hours ago)
Joined: 11 Jul 2016
Posts: 652, Topics: 107
Location: Austria

Reputation: 637.7
Votes: 64

Post Posted: 11-03-2019, 21:56:00 | Translate post to: ... (Click for more languages)

So reducing the dmg modifier he gets with 51 traits: -25.5% dmg increase passive -5% dmg increase [Forbidden Flame] -10% dmg increase [Will of the Conclave]
it is quite accurate to calculate his healing.

Goal: 53322 > 21813

Math:
-53322 x 0.745 = 39725 x 0.95 = 37738.6 x 0.9 = 33964.78 base dmg
-33964.78 x 0.56.1 = 19054.2 base heal
-19054.2 x 1.05 = 20006.9 x 1.1 = 22007.6 final result

(small derivation as 56.1% mastery could actually be something between 56.05%-56.14%)

So can confirm that artifact dmg modifier should not increase atonement healing.

Here people discuss about this topic too and say that passive weapon dmg did never increase atonement heal:
https://us.battle.net/forums/en/wow/topic/20758447049

Regarding 7.2.5 changes to give disc also 15% more healing like all other healers the dmg increase from these traits does no longer count towards atonement too.
Maybe check a few more videos to 100% confirm this, no time to dig deeper rn.

2 0
  
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
bosfreak12

[Purple Dinosaur ]



Status: Offline
(online 26 min ago)
Joined: 09 Apr 2013
Posts: 192, Topics: 26
Location: United States of The Netherlands

Reputation: 138.8
Votes: 18

     
Post Posted: 12-03-2019, 02:32:42 | Translate post to: ... (Click for more languages)

"Essentially this is what is happening. Your damage increase from your artifact doesn't transfer to into healing. You have to do the math, and remove that bonus. Seems kind of silly, but its just how it works *shrug*" from the Blizzard forum.
Elvenking already did the calculations and this seems to be correct.

When I tested it i did:

331899 damage with smite and 200304 healing with my atonement
I have 52.2% Mastery and 4.93% Versatility
331899*.71*.95*.90===201479 "true" damage. what this means is that instead of the 200304 healing the spell is doing right now it should be doing:
201497*.522*1.0493===127462 healing, which in turn seems way too low again.

*edit* I forgot to apply the healing bonus to the 127462 figure, meaning that the healing should be:
127462*1.1*1.05===147219, which is of course a pretty big difference.

*EDIT2*

I've made a spreadsheet with various calculations and using data from a few different youtube videos, what I've concluded from this is that the damage modifiers from all artifact traits should be subtracted from the actual damage done before applying the atonement calcuation, I'm still about 1% off here but I think that is more due to rounding errors and information discrepancy.

Spoiler:

Here's the sheet.

It should be self explanatory -


XXX Barney

Barney's Shadow Priest Guide
Barney's Holy Priest Guide




Last edited by bosfreak12 on 25-03-2019, 16:20:27; edited 1 time in total
2 0
  
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Quicksand

[WoW Dev]



Status: Offline
(online 8 hours ago)
Joined: 21 Feb 2017
Posts: 6019, Topics: 269
Location: Romania

Reputation: 1230.3
Votes: 186

Post Posted: 27-03-2019, 01:56:54 | Translate post to: ... (Click for more languages)

Basically, all "Mod Damage Done %" effects are removed from atonement healing (such as https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=241148)

However, spells that modify specific spell's damage will NOT be reduced (such as discipline priest's passive https://www.wow-freakz.com/spells.php?spell=137032&&name=discipline-priest and all "Add Spell Modifier %" effects)

Fixed.

1 0
  
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message

  Topic locked


Topic is closed, you cannot post any messages in it anymore

Locked by Quicksand, 27 March 2019 00:56



 
This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics.   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    Freakz Forum Index -> WoW Freakz - Legion -> Bug Report -> Fixed bugs  


The time now is 24-04-2019, 21:00:34
Copyright info

Based on phpBB ro/com

 
 
 







I forgot my password


This message appears only once, so
like us now until it's too late ! :D
x